We’ve had a few hot topics about new hiking/parking fees in the Columbia River Gorge and Central Oregon. This got me thinking about our old friend, the NW Forest Pass.
The Forest Service’s legal authority to charge for the NWFP at wilderness trailheads is clearly limited to sites that have all of the following:
“A permanent toilet facility” AND
“A permanent trash receptacle” AND
“Picnic tables”
16 USC § 6802
Here is the current list of sites that charge:
https://www.fs.usda.gov/detailfull/r6/p ... width=full
Question: In your experience hiking at trailheads that require the NWFP, do they always have these three items? If not, please list the trailhead that you have visited and which item it lacks (permanent toilet, permanent trash, or picnic tables). Thanks!
P.S. There is separate authority that says you have to use these facilities to be charged for the NWFP, but I am asking a simpler question: Do these sites even have the items to begin with?
NW Forest Pass and Missing Amenities
- cunningkeith
- Posts: 209
- Joined: June 26th, 2010, 4:28 am
- Location: Portland
- retired jerry
- Posts: 14398
- Joined: May 28th, 2008, 10:03 pm
Re: NW Forest Pass and Missing Amenities
quick scan - yes, they have the three amenities - Cloud Cap, Badger Creek, Burnt Lake North, Ramona Falls,...
Another story - they should be able to use NWFP fees to maintain trails, not have to have those amenities. Or, better yet, fund it from federal income tax. Either of those require congressional action. But we've discussed all that before ad nauseam
Another story - they should be able to use NWFP fees to maintain trails, not have to have those amenities. Or, better yet, fund it from federal income tax. Either of those require congressional action. But we've discussed all that before ad nauseam
Re: NW Forest Pass and Missing Amenities
I'm not clear what the courts have defined as falling in the category of "permanent toilet facility". Sometimes there are one or more porta-potties located at a trailhead serving this purpose and if they are well-maintained I can't see getting all up in arms because they aren't a permanent structure. I've seen some "permanent" outhouses far worse than the average porta-potty. For me the issue is functionality, not permanence.
Re: NW Forest Pass and Missing Amenities
Looking at the Gorge trailheads, it's surprising how few apparently require the pass now. (It used to be "all" of them based on the FS's assertion that the whole area was like one big TH and the amenities for one TH could be down the road at another and still count. They seem to have dropped that premise.)
Dog, Eagle Creek, Bridge of the Gods, Wyeth, and the Larch Mtn summit THs obviously have all the amenities. I cannot recall if Herman Creek and Bonneville have picnic tables (they have bathrooms and trash cans). Herman may have its picnic tables slightly down the road from the TH parking area, in which case one might ask whether a reasonable person driving to the TH and parking in the main parking area would consider a picnic area back down the road to be included for fee purposes when that spot isn't relevant for hiking.
I am pretty sure that Wahclella does not have a picnic table. It has a trash can and a "permanent" porta-pottie. If there were a table it would have to be down the trail, since that TH is so tiny where would they put it?
Ape Canyon in MSH does not have any amenities, I don't think. All the amenities are possibly at the Lava Canyon Interpretive Site, which is nearby around a bend in the road, but again that is reasonably a separate area for someone driving to Ape Canyon just to hike.
Dog, Eagle Creek, Bridge of the Gods, Wyeth, and the Larch Mtn summit THs obviously have all the amenities. I cannot recall if Herman Creek and Bonneville have picnic tables (they have bathrooms and trash cans). Herman may have its picnic tables slightly down the road from the TH parking area, in which case one might ask whether a reasonable person driving to the TH and parking in the main parking area would consider a picnic area back down the road to be included for fee purposes when that spot isn't relevant for hiking.
I am pretty sure that Wahclella does not have a picnic table. It has a trash can and a "permanent" porta-pottie. If there were a table it would have to be down the trail, since that TH is so tiny where would they put it?
Ape Canyon in MSH does not have any amenities, I don't think. All the amenities are possibly at the Lava Canyon Interpretive Site, which is nearby around a bend in the road, but again that is reasonably a separate area for someone driving to Ape Canyon just to hike.
#pnw #bestlife #bitingflies #favoriteyellowcap #neverdispleased
- cunningkeith
- Posts: 209
- Joined: June 26th, 2010, 4:28 am
- Location: Portland
Re: NW Forest Pass and Missing Amenities
“The Forest Service's definition of the term ‘permanent toilet facility’ to include port-a-potties, even if they are predictably present at a site during its open season, is simply not persuasive . . . .” Wiechers v. Moore (E.D. Cal. Apr. 10, 2014)Aimless wrote: ↑February 20th, 2019, 8:37 amI'm not clear what the courts have defined as falling in the category of "permanent toilet facility". Sometimes there are one or more porta-potties located at a trailhead serving this purpose and if they are well-maintained I can't see getting all up in arms because they aren't a permanent structure. I've seen some "permanent" outhouses far worse than the average porta-potty. For me the issue is functionality, not permanence.
Re: NW Forest Pass and Missing Amenities
If that is quoting from the judge's opinion, then I guess for that judge the issue is permanence, not functionality. Using that definition, I think OH.org members can probably identify a fair number of PNW trailheads that do not sport "permanent toilet facilities", yet the FS states that they require a NWFP. Let's pool all your $30 annual fees* and sue!
*I have a Senior Interagency Pass, and no longer need to buy the NWFP. Sorry.
*I have a Senior Interagency Pass, and no longer need to buy the NWFP. Sorry.
- retired jerry
- Posts: 14398
- Joined: May 28th, 2008, 10:03 pm
Re: NW Forest Pass and Missing Amenities
Heyyy... you're just trying to rile people up
For some reason, with the NWFP it's easy to do
Permanent - "lasting or intended to last or remain unchanged indefinitely"
each year they put up the port-a-potty. Unchanged indefinitely. Every summer it's the same.
They did a construction project on my house. They had a port-a-potty put in for a couple weeks. That's temporary.
The old wooden outhouses lasted a few decades before they have to be replaced. Does that mean they're not permanent? No human structures are permanent if you want to think of it that way. In 4 billion years the sun will become a red giant and consume the earth, so therefor the earth isn't permanent.
Okay, I'm probably just trolling
For some reason, with the NWFP it's easy to do
Permanent - "lasting or intended to last or remain unchanged indefinitely"
each year they put up the port-a-potty. Unchanged indefinitely. Every summer it's the same.
They did a construction project on my house. They had a port-a-potty put in for a couple weeks. That's temporary.
The old wooden outhouses lasted a few decades before they have to be replaced. Does that mean they're not permanent? No human structures are permanent if you want to think of it that way. In 4 billion years the sun will become a red giant and consume the earth, so therefor the earth isn't permanent.
Okay, I'm probably just trolling
Re: NW Forest Pass and Missing Amenities
Dog Mt. only has picnic table, not picnic tables.
Re: NW Forest Pass and Missing Amenities
A whole bunch if not most trails only have one picnic table, often just tossed into the trees just so they can require for the pass. examples Mirror Lake, Top Spur, Burnt Lake, Ramona Falls.
- retired jerry
- Posts: 14398
- Joined: May 28th, 2008, 10:03 pm
Re: NW Forest Pass and Missing Amenities
they only need one picnic table to meet the legal requirements
yeah, I like how often the picnic table is in the trees, doesn't appear to ever be used
North Burnt Lake trailhead is another. As I remember, it's slowly rotting away. I wonder how rotted it can be and still qualify
yeah, I like how often the picnic table is in the trees, doesn't appear to ever be used
North Burnt Lake trailhead is another. As I remember, it's slowly rotting away. I wonder how rotted it can be and still qualify